"Never the twain shall meet" was Kipling's take on the whole matter, but that seems to have been the general consensus for centuries before him, still is, and looks set to continue into the forseeable future. So, who coined the concepts of "East" and "West"? And can the world be neatly slotted into one or the other? And are these valid distinctions in the first place?
These are a some of the questions that will be explored in this first post. I chose this topic partly because I've been glancing though a rather interesting book, "Why the West Rules - For Now" by Ian Morris. Also, because this blog is about history (or rather, my take on it), and this basic division of the world's cultures seems to be a good place to start.
Let's start by defining "East" and "West". Right away, we run into trouble. If you ask the average person, they would reply that Europe and its offshoots (North and South America, Australia and New Zealand) were the West, and everything else the East. Straightaway, it's apparent that the division is a cultural one, not geographical - after all, Australia and New Zealand are further east than most Asian countries. Let's accept them as cultural terms, then. But now, we've touched on something important - this definition could as easily be termed "European" and "Non-European"; and that is, in fact, the present-day definition. Europe and the cultures that have sprung from it on the one hand, and everybody else lumped together on the other.
Even that, though, isn't really watertight. Where does sub-Saharan Africa fit in, for instance (Arab North Africa is part of the "Orient" in its broadest sense)? It's obviously not got anything to do with Eastern (i.e Asian) culture, and never has. Latin America is troublesome as well. At first glance, in terms of language and religion, it seems part of the west. But dig a little deeper, and it's evident that in large swathes of it, European culture rests lightly on a native cultural bedrock. Also, there are important economic and governmental differences (poorer, with a penchant for dictators) that set it apart from what is supposed to characterise the west (prosperity, democracy). This was brought home to me by a statement made by the former president of Brazil, Luis Inacio Lula da Silva in 2009, blaming "white people with blue eyes" for the economic crisis in full swing then. Rather than being racist, he was differentiating his world from the European one. Perhaps, then, there should be a "South" in addition to "East" and "West"?
So who first came up with the concept of East and West? I don't know for sure, but one of the earliest culprits seem to have been the ancient Greeks, who coined the names Europe and Asia to refer to the landmasses on either side of the Aegean sea. However, since Greek city-states existed on both sides of this division, it seems to have been a purely geographical division to begin with. Later, however, the term "Asia" acquired a wider meaning, encompassing the Greeks' great enemy, Persia, and the lands of the eastern Mediterranean, and eventually India. But Persia is important - the Greeks had a love-hate relationship with it, admiring its vastness and power, but accutely conscious of the threat it represented to themselves. Much has been made of the conflic between the two, and it's connotations for the world today - the Greeks, supposedly, had democracy and the Persians represented autocracy in the form of their Shahenshah, or Great King. The ultimate defeat of the Persians was seen as a triumph of the West, helping to preserve ideas of democracy and liberalism, to be passed down to their natural inheritors, today's Europeans.
Yes, democracy of a sort did exist in some Greek states; and Persia was an autocratic empire. But democracy never spread widely in Greece, and the Persians' final defeat came about at the hands of Alexander, who had previously united the Greek city-states under his own autocratic rule. As for today's Europe being the natural inheritors of all that was good about Greece - an ancient Greek would have thrown up his hands in horror at the thought. To them, the "civilised world" apart from themselves, was the eastern Mediterranean shore, Egypt and, begrudgingly, Persia (today's Arab world and Iran). Alexander's path of conquest led eastwards, not west - after all, there was nothing worth conquering west of Greece, other than people whose tongues sounded like "bar-bar" to the Greek ear - the origin of the term "barbarian".
But the fact is, Europe has indeed inherited much of Greek thought and philosophy. But is Europe the only recipent of their high culture? Of course not - Sukrat (Socrates) and "falsafa" (Philosophy) are as much a part of Arab (and by extension, Islamic) culture as European. In fact - after the Romans, who heavily copied Greek culture, the first translators and commentators of Greek works were Arabs, who preserved and built on their works. After the Roman empire collapsed in around 400 AD, western Europe lost access to Greek ideas for centuries - only rediscovering them during the Renaissance, when scholars from western Europe began to attend universities in Arab-ruled Spain.
A final irony, gleaned, again, from the pages of Morris' excellent book - he traces the origin of Eastern and Western culture back to two "hotspots" of agricultural and husbanding activity in late prehistory - the former in northern China, and the latter in West Asia, in the region where Turkey, Iraq and Syria come together. According to him, all the crops and farm animals familiar to Europeans were first domesticated here. These then spread to Europe, possibly along with Indo-European languages, that may have originated in this region as well. And today, this region - the cadle of the West - is firmly part of the so-called East.
No comments:
Post a Comment